1994-05-31CONSEI%VATION COMMIMION
BEVEI"IhY, MASSACHUSETTS
~ ~" 31. 1994 MEETING
Mi):'UTES ~,,~ :,-.¥
Ci{Ai RM. AN r ~'~: ~ = .
V .... ~,~._ COTREAU. CLAYTON SMALL
GLENN TERRY, ~Z~,YO ~r,~:.~=r,:, DAVID LAND
BiLL LiSS AND NANCY LODGE.
~,.;.~,:a MOTzv~mD m,--, RECESS wr:m ~=~ ~mLrC ~-=Amr~a ~w~v~ ....
ALL iN FAVOR.
FiF..=.~ ::~anvt..'-,-- ..... ~ :~" . .............. SWVM~:VNG POOL.
- ~. .............. ;._,-..-.7_.~ ~n,~'m 4 ;~:%r~-z CIRCLE ......
'_~[E ~-ROTE, : !S TO .... ~- _ ...... ~ ... LAST
~ ~* ~'-C~ REPLACE ~ EXiST?iG P%~ W~muw muE 20 .
O~- TFTE E;U.~-.. ER~..~-n?=,.~. m~=..,_ AREA BETWEE~ mw~...... POOL AND BROOK ~S, AN .._.~,L
'-- ~"~:"~'~ :-~':'-L ~ur ..... _,. .~. ~L~ ~.~.u ~ .:~';
............. ~:'~=~ '- _..~ A~PL!Ca~:T r~ ~.~ PLACE }!AY ?.. ES ~ '"~ ' ~-L~A~-'~'''
F?iCE C:'.~ '?EE PLA3':. ~! PLAh' FOR THE F!LE~.
.... ~"~ ..... /'~ - A;~'&ED W~'~ KiND C:F EQUIPMENT WiLL m~ USEZ A?rD
CO~T~.ACTOR - A BACKHOE WiLL B= ~rD EXCAVATED ,~A.-R.-n~ WiLL
~,'...... ..'~;:~. _ ,'".~.'.. ~'~:;.._ :.~.~ ~.r~ ..~.... ~:=.. _ M.AYBALE5 Li['~E . ~.~,,r,..; T~E E.i.qCEARGE :""= m;'=_ ._
WA'?ER ~'" .... w~ pU~: BEFORE A}{ ORDER ~'~ '" ........
, ...................... O~,~.:.; z ~; .... i~ iSSUED'.
SECOND HEARING: BiR~RELLI #5-459 71 WATER STREET
BULKHEAD PROJECT.
REPRESENTING, DANIEL LYNCH, ENGR. FROM MARBLEHEAD.
THE PROJECT WILL BE TO REPLACE THE BULKHEAD (24').
CHAIRMAN - HOW WILL THE BULKHEAD BE TAKEN DOWN AND THE NEW ONE
iNSTALLED?
THE CONTRACTOR DID NOT SHOW UP.
BIRARELLi (.THE APPLICANT) - SO LONG AS THE STEEL SHEETING IS THERE
THERE WILL NOT. BE.A PROBLEM.
THE WORK WILL BE DONE FROM THE BARGE.
BiLL LISS - MOTIONED TO CONTINUE TIL JUNE 2tST AND THE CONTRACTOR
IS TO BE PRESENT, CLAYTON SMALL SECONDED T~E MOTION.
ALL iN FAVOR.
.._~.,~_:.,~. BiLL LISS MADE m~E~.. MOTION TO DO SO, A~D =~'-'' TERRY
SECONDED.
ALL
i~ FAVOR.
CERTiFiCATE OF COMPLIANCE SANTiN 123 BRiMBAL AVENUE ~5-iI0.
CLAYTQ~ S~.LL- THE AREA LOOKS STABiLIZFD.
Bi%L 5i£5 VIEWED THE SiTE AND MOTIONED TO GRANT THE CERTiFiCATE AND
CLAYTOM SF~%LL SECONDED THE MOTION.
ALL iN FAVOR.
DISCUSSION WiTH SUSAN ALVEY AT 107 GROVER STREET LOT I0
TREE CUTTING. ALVEY STATED THAT TWO TREES WERE LEANING ON TO HER
MOUSE i0' ~D 25' BOTH 100' PINES. NOT PLANNING TO DO ANYMORE
CUTTING.
CLAYTON SMALL - WANTS TO INSPECT SiTE UPON APPLICANT'S APPROVAL.
DiSCUSSiON WT~H AROLYN ~vc~,~r~ m ~" BEACH ~,r.=~ OLD
D;'""..'"~"',.~M, TNA,'?T;~:'~ !.%T~"W ~O~TC ~
RASLRQAD T~.CKS. BUiLDiNG WT~_.~. AN OLD DETERMiNATiON ~,.~'~-~.~°'~'".
?O EE-Fi~E FOR ~w;
.... ~- A.~ .........DETERMiNATiON, TO SP~OW ~ HOUSE W~'~E IT
~ BEi~fG BUILT.
BiLL LiSS- ,~'~c~ra?-n~u~._u.,~ ...... W%'y NOW A NEW DETERMiNATiON
C~A2RMA~f - MEMBERS SP}OULD LOOK AWD MAKE A DECISION.
..... ~ ~ -:" ARE 'POT?OLEg ~r m~;" ROAD ~OW. ',,m~=
COXF'LE?5 ='~= WA?ER Wx~ =:' DSVFRTED AND wii.~ ,: ...... ~ .....
MAYO JOHNSON WE ARE TO COMPLY ~,7~ THE REGULATiOIgS. ~t, EF-FIL~
GLE~N TERRY SECONDED.
ALL IN FAVOR.
CARRIAGE HILL REALTY TRUST DANIEL FiNN 759 HALE STREET
THE ENTIRE PROJECT WAS EXPLAINED IN DETAIL AND A PLAN WAS
DISPLAYED. ALSO PRESENT, ENGINEER, MIKE JULiANO FROM MERIDIAN
ENGiNEERiNG IN PEABODY.
THE PROJECT IS TO MOVE THE EXISTING DWELLING iNTO T~E BUFFER ZONE
AND TO BUILD A 250' ROAD WITH A CUL DE SAC WITH ADDITIONAL LOTS.
A SILTATION FENCE WILL BE INSTALLED ALL AROUND THE BROOK TO PREVENT
EROSION.
THE ENGINEER - TO GO OVER THE ROADWAY. SITE DRAINAGE CALCULATIONS.
THE DRAINAGE FLOWS TOWARDS THE CATCH BASINS AND TO FLOW INTO A
STORMWATER LEACHING FACILITY. THE FIRST HALF INCH OVER A 24-~OUR
PERIOD THEN THE STORMWATER FLOWS THROUGH A GRASSY SWALE.
DAVID LANG - RE: RETENTION BASIN FOR T~E FIRST FLUS~ AND Wi{ERE IT
WIL~ GO?
ENGR. - IT WILL GO BETWEEN LOTS I AND 2. (8'X20') 2' DEPTH. TWO
PRECAST DRYWELLS LIKE A SEPTIC SYSTFJ4. THE SOIL UNDERNEATH TREATS
THE WATER. NO CLEANOUT SYSTEM. POLLUTANTS WiLL BE TREATED TO TME
SOIL.
SEASONAL GROUNDWATER OCCURS 2 WEEKS IN APRIL AND IN THE BEGINNING
,~u-~ MAY.
RiLL L~e - SUMMARIZE ~,~-w .
...... ~,,_ CHANGES iN THE RUNOFF ~PRESENT AND
ENGINEER - THE EXISTING IS DRAINING TOWARDS THE BROOK. THE HIG~
PC, i~T lZ ON Vi~E STREET,
THE PROPOSED iS TREATED WITH A LEACHING FACILITY (RE: THE BROOK),
~,~,:,~ ~D~,. WiLL IMPACT ~OMEBODY'S HOUSE?
EN'GiMEER - iT wiLL D~IN TOWkRDS THE ROADWAY. THE REAR OF THE LOTS
wiLL DRA~N OVE~ LAND. THERE WILL BE NO PEAK FLOW iNCREASES. THE
CATCH BASINS DO HAVE OiL AND GREASE TRAPS.
,~A,.~ ~.-,NG - SIZE OF LOTS AND T~E PEEV1OUS COVER?
~'r~¢M ' ~" - 30 . 400 LiViNG SPACE
- ~T SIZES GO FROM 10-,200 ,000 ~2, ' OF .
D:.AVX~ '~.;.~.~.",'~ - wwo... WiLL ~,iNTAZN T.nm'~-'~VL.,_. AND GREASE TRAPS?
- _ .... ...~. ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ~OADWAY AND THE
UT~LiTiES.
DAVID 5AMG - RE: ~STORY OF FLOOD!MG OM MALE STREET AND 4' DOWN
· .~ t~ ~. ~.,~G_ WATER AND DISPLACEMENT AND ~OW MUCH?
ET-:PF:.-, - - :'~OT ~c~N~ FLOODING
~.~.,nt:z.m OF mw~ ~'¢ FLOWS.
............. - :~!E.;~. AR~. C~GN!FiCANT AMOUNTK OF ~=~VVr~=~ A~EAS.
~.~, oa~'~ ~:E: ~AGE ~ .tN THE N.O.i ~WrLDLr~= 7~A~iTAT.
iT =:-';'s,;~ A~; AREA OF .66 -PERVIOUS
.. - ~: .... i8, SQUARE FEET,
:'w~'N~ ~W~ AREA ON THE M~P/Pi,.AN
GENERAL PUBLIC
COUNCi~O? JACX MUPRAY 2.~ ACRES ......... R ...... N.~,I./WILDLIFE
HA~!TAT .... .~- ~"~ THE wv~wr,A~ iS W~ERE '~E XOUSE rc TI~E
~:.,~ WAS F~D~D ~'~ ~ LAST TEN YEAES
ENGR. - ZT DRAiMS DOWN AS IT EXISTS TODAY iN A NORTHEASTERLY
DIRECTION AND THE PROPERTIES ALONG VINE STREET-THE HIGH AREA AS IT
DRAINS DOWN TO THE BROOK.
HILDE FEUERBACH - GLOVSKY & GLOVSKY LAW FIRM iN BEVERLY (WITH THE
OPPOSITION) REPRESENTING LELAND TUDOR. REFERRED TO THE BEVERLY
TIMES AND THE BOTCHED UP AD. IT WAS PUT IN BY THE CLERK (MYSELF)
BOTH CORRECTLY AND AT A PROPER TIME. ON MONDAY, MAY 23, 1994,
fTHEREFORE, ALLOWING FOR THE MEMORIAL DAY MONDAY HOLIDAY), BUT THE
BEVERLY TIMES APOLOGIZED TO THE APPLICANT AND PUT IT IN THE PAPER
ON A WEDNESDAY. MAY 25, 1994 (CORRECTLY). TOO LATE ACCORDING THE
OPPOSITION. AND ALSO STATED THAT TO ACQUIRE A COPY OF THE NOTICE
OF INTENT WOULD COST $35.00.
TWO IMPORTANT FACTORS - ONE BEING THE RESIDENTS WERE NOT GIVEN 5
FULL DAYS NOTIFICATION BEFORE THE HEARING (AS EXPLAINED ABOVE), AND
THE SECOND BEING THE VERNAL POOL FACTOR.
DANIEL O"ROURKE OF 21 VINE STREET
LA,ND IS A SWAMP, KIDS HAVE SKATED THERE IN THE WINTER AND
DUCKS AND ALSO PEEPERS WERE SEEN THERE. THE O'CONNORS HAVE FILLED
THE LAND.
JAI' FiLOMENA 0= 23 OAK ~-m ~0m A DIRECT ABUTTER .~.T~E PROPERTY
.,,~'~;~.~?~., WE?TEE FOR ??E-, ~ PAST '~ ~'EARS.
DEBRA GOESELiNE OF 23-n~-~"~'~=v S~... READ A LETTER ALOUD AND iT iS ON
_~'2~E~, -,.-.',.~'""";' .... .... .~4cM~=R ?.~AS .h CC'PY.
WILSON OF 149 VALLEY STREET ALSO OPPOSED. RE: TO Tt{E CATCH
............. _r..E.~ ~ ,.~m-
..... ~,:O A CATC}~ BASIN AND 50,000 SQUARE FEET
SURFACE AREA DRAiNiNG INTO THE AREA, IT OVERPOWERS THE CATC~
BAS?~ "A LACK OF CAPACITY".
M~.R.K LOGAN OF 8 CHUBBS BROOK LANE - ABUTTER AND HE 9EAD ALOUD A
LETTER FROM JEERS; D'~APOLi C'F 6 CHUBBS BROOK LANE, BE_r.'DG MUCF C'F
CHURBS BKOOK LA?~'E !~,~ A FLOOD AREA. (TO BE PLACED ON FILE.
LC:C4A?~ - 70% OF F2S BACKYA~D ]S YN WATER. LOT 4 USED TC
NOW iT ~RAiNS i};'?O LOGA~i'S B.ACFYAF'.D. IF THiS PROJECT GOES T~-.F.O.L;G~
LOGA?~'5 BACKYARD WiLL BE TOTALL%' UNDER WATER.
THE FRONT OF HER" ........ ~'~' .....r~;~
J!~ POLASi OF 809 ~A'LE STREET - ALSO IN OPPOSiTiOn-~.
"?."51?r~ CiE.-'~!'_-..' ?i~'.;E'' .
STATEO
~r~m~ 759 STREET),
CAR.~,u~ TALBOT.
..- ~' SUMP ~U"~C DUE TO ALL T~E FiLL
~;';~;"~ '--~'s PUMP .~"~'~' BASEME.~T 'rS '~-; ~' LOWER m~;"~ ,~ ~'~'~.~ '.')~
m~ ?~uu~, ;T ~S SEASONAL WA:_.R iN THE LOWER BASE.N'F~'~T WEEN THE
~{OUSE iS MOVED NO SUMP PUMP WILL BE NEEDED.
RENEE MARY OF 274 HALE STREET
RE: VOLUME VELOCITY OF THE BROOK, AND ALSO TAINT THIS HEARING BE
CONTINUED.
CHAIRMAN STATED IT IS UP TO THE APPLICANT.
RITA MASFORALL - STATED WHEN LIVIN~ AT 759 f~LE ST., SHE NEVER HAD
A SUF~ PUMP.
COUNCILLOR MURRAY - IT IS A REASONABLE ASSUMPTION THAT NOW IT IS
A WETLAND, NOW A SUMP PUMP IS NEEDED.
JOHN ALESSANDRO OF 808 HALE STREET OPPOSED ALSO, RE: TO THE
WATERSHED AREA AND THE' SQUARE FOOTAGE. THE CATCH BASIN IS NOT
LARGE ENOUGH.
_~N:~ - THE WATER mA~L~ ~S ~' BELOW SURFACE, SEASONAL WATER TABLE -
2~_. 5:0NE AREA ,,.',-S 30'
WALKER MARTi,~i OF 19 ViNE STREET - RE: TO T.".{i~ AS A PIECEMEAL
REQUEST ~w;-~T::w~ ~,~..~'~ C..'THER ?~)USEC Wi{Y iS ~w~. NOT TREATED .AS
AN ENTIRE £UBDIViSiON.
................. ~.V~.~.~-.Ga FOOTPRINT BEFORE US HE
m-...-~rww.~? - T~.,i APPLICANT
W~LL BE ........ ~,aR m~T~ c..: ..... ._
D.-, ~ ~, ........ '%?':.'7.'~.
JAY FOLOMENA OF 22 ()AX 'STREET- THE PROPERTY SHOULD RETURN TO iTS
F(,RMER n~: ~T; THE ~r, --, ~ · ~ ~
...~..~. LA~ ~ WAS ~,,~.,GA~Y FILLED.
COUNCILLOR MURRAY - LOT 4 - THERE WERE SEEDLING TREES THERE, WAS
T~RE PERMiSSiON TO TAKE THEM DOWN.
FTN..~ SUBMITTED TO '~'~' m~"~T'~-~-IONERS AT ,,~:: TIME, A LETTER FROM
DAVID ..",A%iG - RE: TO A 1987 P~'."~TO. gAS ANYONE VIEWED iT.
~-,:~- ...... ~...~..,~.~,-,...3 - ~O'~m~ FOR 3-I/2 YEARS. TODAY
ZT r~ .................. p~'~.~v.~r-,v D~'-~ ......... T~{E BULK OF T~{E ~TLLTNf: TOOK PLACE 2 YEARS
AGO.
....... - -~..~,: ~.~ ~(~ .... ~- HEARING.
"'~'~' 50~GE AS ~O;~ THE ~.'=TG'~n~T~,- '"'~:='" '~ ..... 0
C,-', ,*.~. .' - WE 2i ~'~- b'J~KE "£['~'E u-C_-r''~'~
..... ~ ....... a,. ?AVE u~.x;~ TO .~.~ r,~ ....., BEFORE T~E HEARING
..... WI~.~
iS CLOSED, WE CANNOT ViEW THE SiTE AM A G~OUP, IT '' BE
~..',.~,~c--v:~- PUB' [C ~w:~
E./LDE FEUERBACB - RE: PUBLIC HEARINGS, READ FROM THE REGULATIONS
REGARD~.NG TO CONTINUE.
BiLL ~i~;~ .... "~7~-n~.,,~&,,/~ ~O.. CO~TfNUE THiS WiTHiN' THE 2~ DAYS [LIMIT AND
TO A ~iTE ViSiT ON SUNDAY @ !~:00 A.M., GLENN TERRY SECONDED THE
MOTION.
ALL IN FAVOR.
SPECIAL MEETING TUESDAY EVENING JUNE 7TH.
ABUTTERS ARE NOT ALLOWED ON THE PROPERTY.
THEREFORE, ABUTTERS FROM 149 VALLEY ST. AND 5 CHUBBS BROOK LANE.
IN-SITE PEOPLE TO VIEW 759 HALE STREET FROM THEIR PROPERTIES.
LOGAN ALSO INVITES PEOPLE ONTO MIS PROPERTY (8 CHUBBS BROOK LANE).
DAVID LANG - REFERRED TO A HEAVY RAINSTORM, WANTS TO GO ONTO THE
PROPERTY AFTER ONE.
MEETING ADJOURNED AT 10:10 P.M. MOTIONED BY CLAYTON SMALL, AND
SECONDED BY GLENN TERRY.
MARIE S. COTREAU/CLERK