2009-02-18
CITY OF BEVERLY
PUBLIC MEETING MINUTES
Board:
Harbor Management Authority
Date:
February 18, 2009
Location:
Beverly Public Library - Fogg Room
Members Present
Chair, Miranda Gooding, Charles Raymond, Greg Ward
Paul Miedzionowski, Don Neuman, Maureen Troubetaris,
Rinus Oosthoek, Wes Slate, Sylvan Menezes, George Simon
Members Absent:
None
Others Present:
Lou Bochynski, Eileen Sacco - Recorder
Gooding called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m.
Approval of Minutes
The minutes of the Harbor Management Authority meeting held on January 21,2009 were
presented for approval. Oosthoek moves to approve the minutes of the Harbor Management
Authority meeting held on January 21,2009 as amended. Slate seconds the motion the motion
carnes.
Report from Facilities Committee
Ward reports that the Facilities Committee met this evening and are recommending that the
summer rates for the commercial boaters be increased from $76 per foot to $80 per foot. He
explains that this is slightly less than 5%, and notes that the HMA did not raise the rates last
year.
Oosthoek moves to accept the recommendation of the Facilities Committee and set the
Commercial Fees for the 2009 season at $80.00 per foot. Slate seconds the motion. The motion
carnes.
Ward reported that the Facilities Committee discussed the electricity issue and the consensus was
to let it ride for now until we get it cleared out. Bochynski explained the process of billing,
meter reading, and the collection and processing of payments. Discussion ensues regarding the
tracking of electricity and the accounting of the payments. Oosthoek states that it can be worked
out.
Ward reported that one recreational and two commercial tenants have been turned over to Mr.
Monroe for collection action. Bochynski reported that he provided Mr. Monroe with
documentation and he will be reviewing it.
Harbor Management Authority
February 18, 2009
Page 1 of 4
Finance Report
Harbor Improvements
Gooding reported that she, along with Oosthoek, Neuman, and others have been working with
Vine Associates to break down the estimated costs of the marina improvements into phases. She
reviews estimates for the proposed work noting that there are alternates included. She notes
that if the stimulus money does not come in we need to know what we can afford to fund in order
to get the work done at Glovers Wharf. She notes that the estimate of the work that needs to be
done is $2 million dollars.
Oosthoek questioned what had to be done to the area without the Black Cow project. Gooding
explains that the apron and the bulkhead need to be replaced. Neuman notes that we have to
deal with the water side in front of the McDonald's building, noting the bulkhead, gangway and
floats have to be replaced.
Ward notes that in order to keep the revenue coming in we have to replace the floats.
Gooding notes that the Black Cow project is moving along explaining that they have filed with
the Planning Board for site plan review and the public hearing is scheduled for March 17, 2009.
She encouraged all members to attend the meeting to support the project.
Miedzionowski review the monthly financial statement with the HMA members.
Discussion ensued regarding the $40,000 that the city transfers out of the HMA enterprise fund
to the city budget. Ward states that he hopes that the HMA will be able to keep those funds in
the future.
Status of Appropriation ReQuest from Citv Council
Gooding reported that the appropriation request went before the Beverly City Council and
the matter was referred to the Council budget analyst for an opinion. The budget analyst
reported back that she did not think that the Harbor Management Authority is authorized to
spend money and suggested that the Council get an opinion from the DOR.
Gooding explained that an earlier opinion from the budget analyst stated that the HMA does
have the authority to appropriate money, and there is no need to go to the Council for approval.
She further explained that the action of the HMA is subject to revocation by the City Council by
a 2/3 vote within 30 days of the action of the HMA.
Gooding reported that Finance Director John Dunn has recommended that the HMA vote to
ratify the FY09 budget and to also vote to increase the FY09 budget by $100,000 to fund
ongoing engineering consulting contracts with Vine Associates.
Harbor Management Authority
February 18, 2009
Page 2 of 4
Ratifv Harbor Mana2ement Authoritv Bud2et
Oosthoek moved to ratify the current fiscal year 2009 Harbor Management Authority budget,
approved by the Beverly City Council in June 2008, authorizing the expenditure of $177,900
which amount was further augmented by $15,425 encumbrance carried forward from the
previous fiscal period. Miedzionowski seconded the motion. The motion carried.
Appropriation
Oosthoek moved to increase the Harbor Management Authority fiscal year 2009 budget by
$100,000 to fund ongoing engineering, consulting contracts with Vine Associates for harbor
improvements. Ward seconded the motion. The motion carried.
Approval of Revised Scope of Work for Vine Associates
Neuman moved to approve the revised scope of work for Vine Associates to provide additional
services for the Harbor Improvements and the Glovers Wharf Seawall. Oosthoek seconded the
motion. The motion carried.
Discussion ensued regarding the authority of the HMA and Gooding recommended that the
HMA work on this noting that the role of the HMA is unclear in the charter. She suggests that a
subcommittee review the charter to evaluate what makes sense. Ward, Oosthoek and Simon will
serve on the subcommittee.
Licensin2
Neuman reported that he talked to DEP regarding restrictions on piers and there are none.
Menezes reported that he researched this and found that the only community that has restrictions
is Barnstable and explained that the requirement is that people have to be able to walk under a
pier. He explained that this is administered by the Barnstable Conservation Commission.
Gooding stated that if people think it is a significant issue then we could move forward, but
cautioned that if Barnstable is the only community in Massachusetts that has this, she questions
if it is an easy thing to do.
Harbor Management Authority
February 18, 2009
Page 3 of 4
Other Business
BeverlvlSalem Transportation Improvements Proiect 1 Beverlv Harborwalk.
Neuman reported that a meeting was held with the Mayor, Tina Cassidy and Mr. McLaughlin
regarding the walkway plans. Gooding reported that Tina Cassidy gave her a copy preliminary
design report for the project and she emailed it to members. Discussion ensued regarding design
that is preferable to the HMA.
Oosthoek moved that the HMA recommend a modified alternative 3 proposed, in accordance
with Bochynski's recommendations. Troubetaris seconds the motion. The motion carried.
Update on Dred2in2 ProiectIFundin2
Neuman reported that the next step since the approval of the testing the permission to dispose at
sea is for the engineering plan and the permitting process. He stated that Bourne Associates
estimated that it will cost $75,000. He recommended that the HMA put it in the budget for next
year and see what happens. He also noted that the money should come from the Seaport Council
and notes that we are in line for some spare change from this years budget.
Adiournment
There being no further business to come before the Harbor Management Authority this eyeing,
Slate moved to adjourn the meeting. Ward seconds the motion. The motion carries.
The meeting was adjourned at 9:00 p.m.
Harbor Management Authority
February 18, 2009
Page 4 of 4