1988-11-17
.Ir'
\.
MINUTES FROM MEETING ON NOVEMBER 17.1988
MEMBERS PRESENT: Ra~ Bouchard, George Batchelder, Bill Liss, Peter
Gilmore, Nancy Lodge and Vinnie Cotreau
MEETING CALLED "TO ORDER AT 7=50 P.M.
Motion to recess for Public Hearing made by Peter
Seconded by Vinnie
ALL IN F"AVOF.:
#5-321 (continued) CHUBBS BROOK 1025 HALE STREEl
Don Kent, Gulf of Maine Research, represented the applicant.
Hou ~""e.
George commented no vegetation has taken place, since the wetlands
have been cut down.
K(;;;'nt sitElt("=.,d m'~:"UiIJE::' pl'3nting hE..~::; beE'T"i done, W:LJJ "("f.-:;"-E.~valu""~tF~ ,,"~fte;" "Ci!f:?
wi"n"tF')" E:,nd, i"f"" nf2C:E~~;;Sc;\Y""y, Ivlll rE.p.lc:int in th(? ~:;p"("ing"
George: No ha~ baJe~ along the road"
Kent: It will be taken care of immediately.
Chairman to Kent~ Wrong map number listed on Notice of Intent. More
clarificationis needed on botJ the plans and in the Notice, alsc
pertaining to references, and in reference to the driveway, if not
clarified, this could encumber another's property. To amend Notice of
Intent where~eeded.
Information Sufficient Hearing closed
E;i"ng}c,
#5-324 JORDAN BAKER TOZER ROAD
}'-:-j i n i uJa "f"'.e hou S8.. hE,p'r-- es\::?n t i ng , F'e t e)'~ (;{; i"-{2)'} '.I l-l~'::'~~..J e~:~. E:n ':;j in E'C!."(" in C.:J CO ~
A drainage impact analysis submitted at this time.
Ge01"c:J2 rrlc)tiOT12d to talJlc tt':is l~l~oJect: at this .tiIT!e~
FE' tel"" seCUil cJed
,<;I._L H,j Fl;\,'OF<
A five minute overall review at this time was agreed upon (on what was
just submitted).
CONTINUED DECEMBER 1ST
L.AUREL.. RIDGE
"t Cc;nnttItJ. n it w
".Ji'tlst,,*Ae-d
~~,:'t:.~-- -: '_ :'!. -"~};'f;':i': :,; -'::~(
"'-... -.
HALE ST.
atthill tl-. ..e ~(.lkc::dI:n1'lict of int8rll!l!lt-is an
"'
Representing, Steve Leonard.
George: Discript:ior"J (::;"f c:(.:)r.~~~~.tf'U(:~.t:i(~T'l?
The construction manager: Construction equipment will enter and leave
from the west side of the project, will be contained in the snow
fence at alJ times.
MiH -::. r: (jt:-: CJ l"'~ (;;) e P C) ~:::.:::. :1. ~;~~E:fZ~ -I ,~\ "J c. ~-:.~ t 1 . \::.'l:::: t --. cc;n c: E:Y.' n rH. E.:=g ,~.\ Y" cl i n 9 cJy', i 1 1 i n l.:J ./ t.uc~ 1 1 ~
S-l:E-:r\/e L_e(Jnay~d: }~Jastin~.1 u.!llJ h~:i.\/F' fie) (~~f"rect C)'f"! ~it (thi.:? toell)
1'11". DOH.f<:U'" t ~ ei'; P]. c"t i ned t hi':' PUS.1 t i un be i ng 20Vi fE;et aLLla~ fr'uiTl t he we II.
Will test the water before blasting, during the blasting, etc. Will
rebu. i I c! t hE~ we J 1 i f necessa"('~.
George Batchelder: Re: field tripl cu.lverts, Witch Lane.
The construction manager: Extension of pipe- Wetland 2
fe€:?t. /
Wetland 3-8+ feet Totai 24
George: Pipe open on one end?
Answer: Will make a new pIpe and will connect it to the old pipe.
Add 10 feet during construction ,5 feet on either side.
George : upland storage water. Proposed are both downstream.
for detention basins, how will it support the wetlands?
Answer: Will have to re-advert the water flow.
Will still be direct water flow to wetland on
GENEr~AL. PUBL I C
Mr Borgess 233 Hale @t. concerns, again, re : wells! water
Mr. Dowart: Soils on site are relativel~ impermeable. Runoff from
bUildings and parking lot will go into Wetland One. Therefore, will
not contaminate the well. Soils are impervious near the drainage
area. The majority of water is runoff not to percolate into the
ground.
Michael Marcus Sr. Environmentalist New England Environmental Co.
represented the opposition, stated comments ~nd concerns.
Upland detention basins wouldn"t eliminate much wetland alteration.
Feels there is more than 50 feet of bank being altered. Using the
wetland as a detention basin, is a direct alteration.
Virll1ie : questi(:JnE(j if all ~~atpr fJ.O{Ded In an llplaTld, ~lJo~.ild t!1E
wetlands have enough water to su.rvive?
Michael Marcus: Yes
lr:::
-'
1 i ne,:ilr"
I f u~:::"i-:?d
George: H(~llJ c(~t.llc' d~ainage ~!Jai~8r/COl'}1-2IT;inpnts hp ~laJ'ldlEd/avoided?
Marcus: 40% of contaminents are removed by using detention basins.
Steve LeonArd: Reiterated on Mr. Marcu$' comments
Renee Mary 274 Hale St. : Can ~o~ guarantee I'll not be flooded since
I'm downstream?
-Will my p6nd not be destro~ed?
-Will the wildlife, birds not disappear due to the change of their
habitat?
-Woodpeckers depend on the swamps w{ll that be saved?
-Can wou guarantee the wells not be destroyed? I don't trust the
'~fugures. Referred to April 1986 rainstorm bein(.; flooded, etc.
Ben Eisenstadt: Represented the opposite Feels the wetlands are being
used as a filtration plant. Well owners are not being treated fairl~.
A huge stand of helTtloc~:: tt-'ees being removed. Project is too vast. ThE~
applicant should've built around the wetlands, due to Greed, the
applicant continues to keep it big. The commission should deny this
Pt"'oj E'Ct"
Mqtion to close th~ hearing made by Peter
Seconded bw Vinnie
ALL IN FAVOH
5 MINUTE RECESS Ar TH!S TIME
~~I:". C()I\!\/L f\!E:
I~ c: ~J r"~ -I:: )
P j::.'l \/'j .::::. i::~ t.-! F"~ /::, n ~j; I::;
C',
COVE CROSSING SUBDIVISION
~l t tel"!" nE)'..:1 Ch a y"l ,:,:'.:;;, Cn)'" kin J I T r F'pr" (-','~;::,F',n t F'e! t h f" <::, (:iP J i, C,;;\ n t <';, n d
explained/displa~ed the revised plan.
FCJtlln(4) sep~)^ai:p de't:en"l:j,!:JT") 0)^f~2~3 de~~!~::,c::te(j [Jf1 .t:he pfan~ ~"ntd a1. 1-~..~
li!2\tf2\".
Nancy Lodge~ Referred to DEQE finding an intermittent stream
f:3 t r' (0:;" d iT, ":1' E3" "7
4.(~":2 Area Sllb.,iec:"l: '):(:) f100(:1:i119
Petel'~ GilIT!ore~ S.tre~IT! (:1it(~t'l
~.i .:'::\ t f::'~ y.. f:], CI i.!3 E: .:::1. ~:::. t C.i f f' .~. h ,:-::, . ~:::. 1 T: E.! ~. t Cl I...' 1...1 t 'i:: F~{"" C3 !:.-; F: !,N, t LI )
F'::::.,tE:'t'
P,:.:.:.::-!:;::.:.:.y".
r.l i. ) lit I I I . '.'::~ "
l~er;~ ~;(:Jr!'12t:irrle~:~ .flO~!J~~ P2~si:;,~~;(J!.!'!et:i!110S r.!.c:)W!~; t!Jest
~.:..' i ;;:,::
...... .. f., .~~!
,{C., Chi::i.nn(~~J
T' (.; j::'i :. ~:: .i". I=: Ei. i"f!
. . !..'.r j j. E~~: ~:::; t Y'. r::' .:::i, IT! 'f ,...L.!. .j. .. Ff:: '(.. C~ b f? (.::::, .n CJ Lt ';:.1. h i..~.l ;~, t f:'0 ;-" 1:- C) f' '::.:= (::2 c.1 .!:: h r::::.: \/ f.::: ::';1 (;? t E:.i. t ':i, CJ n c.i IT (j
F; {:.,-, '.~..i
:.... E? n ~. k:: 1~:~ ~.:==.
., L n .r!~; " I.f a ~;;:~ t y., (.::.' -::;i, iT! ": i..i..~1. J J ~:l C) u Y.. ;.'7.:' !:::: J ]. c:: E~ 1:~ E:i ?
Petel^ GlIITlol^E,: W1.)211 SC(J(Jj.:~ecj O~l.t:~ lDill YOI.1 Y~2~)licate the 3Y'ee
OgreY.~: Yes (~0 feet of :i.t.,
G (.:::, C) l'~ '3 E~:: .~j. Ej f1 t. '::1 C) ILl n t C) .4 "7' .L; i t h i.:'=;. ;~. t Y.. !:;~...' .:::"1 iTi 'f I,.A) h ~:J t ]. ~::' ~:::. CJ :i]' t ~ P E' ?
()greT'~= Sands and gra :l
George: Construction o~ drainage basin
Ogren: Boundary along Hutt's property.
McKinnon: Drops to elevation 48.6-s1opes down to 47, flat bottom
essentiallY.
LerDY Hutt (abutter) 71 Cross Lane Re: Corner of property. What is,
it? A gul1~ ditch?
Hutt: A gUlly IS" deep 21/2 WIde.
-Water goes under the -oad.
-comes out facing west.
-cor')(:eY'llS reg~r\d:in0 tt.~e eate)~ .t:ablen
. '/
5<-':'0)" (:J c' ~
Ug .,.-, (.:::>n ~
A'ftel^ baSlf) i~~ pl.l.!~
1 r.:
1 C)~; ~:;~. (:) 1"
LU i::'1. \: '=:' .(.
'j'j"'OiTI HU.t
p',.-. u Pi:.':!Y" ':: ~ ./
~~. :L n ---. LM L-: ..../ (-"3 J. :;;;: ..::1' ~3" ~~j
Stein"s
Suzanne Stein displayed Plan showing a 34j acre watershed. Explained
water concerns~ flOOdIng etc. Also, ar0ued about the Intermitted
stream existing. Additional wetlands on the northerly portion.
Quoting Tra~y Peters,DEQE, there is a stream, also a spring that
feeds the stream.
Stein 1.55 2.3 acre (from the spring)
/'li..'\r,Jorfe Hutt To ~'jeter O~~F"(:?n~ Hi0.",I€,,:. ~,:-JOU !;;;e!f.-?n ttHi.' f'2<::d~er-' in thf::' Cove
School Yi~'rd?
.~ OgrEm: No
Chairman Tel the Commission
Is the information su icient?
Bill liss is not satisfied
Pe.'tf'?l'" f"/!otiDT'if."0d '1::0 close the hE.',::i)'"'inc';}.!
P,il1 sE:'conclE:'cl
Alan Taubert: Once closed, can information still be received, also,
any time limits?~
C~'laj_1"!Tlarl : !~(j!\ll~'
Nanc~ Opposed
ALL IN FAVOR
ORDERS OF CONDJ:"rI(:~~lf~
CITY OF BEVERLY PERSHING AVE PUMP SlAl'lON
S'l.'ANI:)AI~DS
MARC LEVIN
ONE WHITMAN PLACE LOT 27
#5-322 STAI~DARDS
VENTOLA 8 FOSTER PT #5-326
STANDARDS AND COASTAL
CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE
lONGFELLOW PLACE #5-195 WILL SUBMIT ENGINEERS REPORT
KELLY NISSAN ~5-300
S1"ILl_ WOR.~ "l-() BE D()NE
JA-BY ENG. S CURTIS #5-24/
FULL
FINN 13 MORNINGSIDE ~RIVE #5-284 FULL
COOK BEAVER POND Lot 4S #5-184
Peter motioned to modification is significant
Bill seconded
ALL IN'FAVOR
A letter to follow.
Motion to adjourn made b~ Peter at 11:15 P.M.
seconded b~ Bill
ALL IN FAVOR
Marie S. Cotreau/ clerk
.~