BHMA Minutes March 17, 2021 Harbor Management Authority
Minutes of March 17, 2021 Meeting
CITY OF BEVERLY
PUBLIC MEETING MINUTES
Board: Harbor Management Authority
Date: March 17, 2021
Location: Virtual via Google Meet
Members Present: Chair Paul Earl, Vice Chair Emily Flaherty, Todd
Callaghan, Larry Herman, Don Neuman, George Simon,
David Suminsby, Estelle Rand, Todd Rotondo
Members Absent: None
Others Present: Sean Ciancarelli (Marina Manager), Kenneth Smith
Recorder: Brett Bauer
Earl calls the meeting to order at 7:00 pm and roll call is taken.
Approval of Minutes
Deferred to the next meeting.
Financials Report
Earl reports that the numbers are in good shape. Ayles has been invited to the next meeting to
discuss next year's budget. Earl would like to discuss how the City tracks expenses and would
prefer to have clearer lines for expenses and revenue. He notes that Ciancarelli cleaned up the
expenses from GZA. Neuman notes that he would like to add a line for the CAD cell grant as
capital income. Earl notes that for the four or so customers that still owe a combined total of
$15k - he would just want them to communicate, have a plan, and follow the plan.
Birarelli Public Access
Neuman reports that Rotondo helped him arrange a meeting with Tom Birarelli. Birarelli is
interested in having a good relationship with the City and expressed interest in being involved
with the HMA. He has said the family has plans to improve the wharf property and Neuman feels
this may be an opportunity to suggest the public access, but Neuman is not sure how the other
members of the family may feel. Earl notes that they would welcome a commercial fisherman on
the HMA. Neuman clarifies for Callaghan that there is no public access to the eastern end of the
Beverly Port Marina property from Water Street.
Customer Parkin
Earl reports they have a final draft of the communications and contingency plan. There are
several options of how to proceed or they can wait and be reactive. Callaghan asks who we think
are currently parking under the bridge. Earl responds that it is mainly commercial marina
customers and individuals fishing from the pier. Rotondo adds that increased parking
enforcement would be very beneficial. Rand notes that she is uncertain if meters were originally
Page
Harbor Management Authority
Minutes of March 17, 2021 Meeting
recommended for this area in the most recent parking study. Simon asks if construction on the
new restaurant does not begin this summer could the lot be opened back up for parking. Earl said
they can reconnect with Marry Bloom.
Kayak/SUP Racks
Earl reports that all but one of the kayak spaces have been leased, and he would like to propose
another rack at Independence and/or Lynch Park. Independence Park seems to be the most
popular. Suminsby asks if there are many SUPS leasing space, as they may be able to adjust the
racks to accommodate additional boats. Earl says there are only two SUPS currently registered.
Rotondo motions to purchase an additional rack for Independence Park. Herman seconds.
Discussion: Callaghan supports an additional rack at this location, but is concerned about
obstructing the view. He feels that Independence Park has some of the best views in the city and
suggests they limit this location to three racks. Earl and Suminsby feel the racks are low enough
to not obstruct views, but they can also consider views in the placement of the racks. With the
cost of the racks at around $2800 to $3000 installed, Rotondo proposes to amend the motion to
approve an amount not to exceed $3500. The motion is approved by roll call, 9-0.
Viewing Machines at Parks
Herman reports that the two companies he found provide machines with different magnification.
One company has 20x, which gives greater distance but a broader view. The other company has
1 Ox, which is less distance but more defined. Herman is not opting for coin-op machines for
concern about maintenance and vandalism. All equipment is available as ADA compliant or not.
Herman notes that ADA compliant machines would also be better for children. Herman has
reached out to the Rotary Club and they would entertain a grant request. He feels that
Independence Park is the favored location. Rotondo is waiting to hear from Gelineau about any
viewing machines that may be available on the state bid list, and he is also in favor of going with
ADA compliant machines. Rand also supports having the duo of the ADA compliant and taller
machine. She would encourage that they be located close to the sidewalk for better accessibility.
She also suggests they consider the new public path at the Sedna Apartments for a location.
Herman notes that there is a SeeCoast machine at Stramski Way in Marblehead. All agree that
the preference is for the Hi-Spy machines. Herman notes that the Rotary Club might be able to
approve a grant prior to the next HMA meeting, and he feels that Hi-Spy machines are probably
in stock and ready to ship, where the SeeCoast machines may need more lead time. Callaghan
recommends they notify Jenna from the Conservation Commission. Earl concludes that they can
discuss locations at the April meeting and take a vote.
Public Pier Planks Replacement
Ciancarelli suggests that the planks should be ordered soon. He notes that the DPW can build the
fish cutting table themselves. He asks if the HMA would contribute an additional $5k for this
project and notes the recent increases to lumber prices. Callaghan motions to approve an
Page
Harbor Management Authority
Minutes of March 17, 2021 Meeting
additional $5k from the HMA for this project. Flaherty seconds. The motion is approved by roll
call, 9-0.
Commercial Hoist Construction Grant& Pier Appendage/Fishing Float EnOneerin2 Grant
Earl reports that he and Neuman discussed the City's share of the grant match for these two
projects with the Mayor. The Mayor asked about how many people would be benefitting from
the hoist pier project. The Mayor verbally approved the City's 50150 split with the HMA for the
required grant match on both projects. Earl suggests three options for writing the grant
application: 1) they could have the engineering firm write it, 2)they could have Catharine Barrett
write it, or 3)the HMA could write the application. Neuman notes that they have six weeks until
the due date, but they need to have a plan. He asks if they can use an engineering firm other than
GZA. Ciancarelli says he would need to discuss that with Mike Collins. Earl would like to start
the application writing process by next week.
Si2nne -Phase 2?
Callaghan suggests this topic be delayed until the May meeting as he needs additional time to
add notes to his spreadsheet regarding sign needs and conditions.
Falco Proposal
Earl reports that City and Falco have agreed to all terms of the contract. The App icon design is
discussed and most people like the first option and suggest making "Marinas" singular.
Obear Park Coastal Resiliency Study
Flaherty reports that a public meeting is coming up on April 15. Rotondo adds that they did get
over 500 surveys completed.
Bass River CAD cell Seaport Grant
Earl is in contact with Mike Collins with regard to a kickoff meeting for this project.
GW Trash
Earl will defer this topic to the next meeting.
Congress Street Pocket Park
Earl has abandoned this as a larger project but could still do a smaller project. Callaghan reports
that a person involved with the CPC that he spoke with indicated that a CPC grant could be used
if the HMA wanted to take on changing the land ownership to permanently protect the area,
meaning the issue is primarily a legal one. This issue could also be discussed at the City Council.
Earl notes that a kayak rack could still be installed, but would probably need approval from the
Conservation Commission. Rotondo and Callaghan suggests they could engage the community
on the project and organize clean-ups of the area. Flaherty notes that Salem Sound Coastwatch is
regularly sending volunteers to this area for clean-ups. Neuman adds that they may just need to
Page
Harbor Management Authority
Minutes of March 17, 2021 Meeting
clear brush and do some grading. Earl concludes that they can discuss what the HMA wants to
invest in this project at a future meeting.
Facilities Committee Report
Ciancarelli reports that piling caps were installed,but has no other updates.
The Facilities Committee reviewed the winter rates for the recreational marina and recommends
keeping the rates the same. Suminsby motions to keep winter rates at the recreational marina the
same. Herman seconds. There is some discussion about whether they should consider raising the
rates. Suminsby notes that the winter rates are currently $50 per foot. Callaghan asks if there is
ever any need or responsibility to break up ice with bubblers. Simon responds that the harbor
hasn't frozen in decades. The motion is approved by roll call, 9-0.
Earl adds that they should further market the winter slips and try to fill them up in future winter
seasons. Earl and Suminsby agree that it may be appropriate to look at raising the regular
recreational rates at the next opportunity. Callaghan asks if it is possible to expand the marina.
Earl responds that it could be challenging because of the proximity to the channel.
Other Comments and Announcements
Earl asks members to please review the NSIV document for a discussion at the next meeting
about a potential role for HMA involvement. Earl also thanks Ciancarelli for his work on getting
out the kayak stickers and installing appropriate signage on the racks with contact information.
Adiournment
There being no further business before the Harbor Management Authority this evening,
Callaghan makes a motion to adjourn. Herman seconds. Motion to adjourn approved by roll call
(9-0).
The HMA Meeting is adjourned at 9:05 pm.
Page